On the first anniversary of Judy's disappearance, "Johnny" takes the girls to an abandoned building in the forest, located near a river, and leaves them as a way to scare them. I should've cried for Katie. Having been sentenced after she confessed to killing her son Riley, Gideon's work as a profiler leads him to believe that Sarah Jean never actually murdered her son and instead gave him away to keep him safe. Abduction and rapeLigature strangulationStabbing (once) There, they meet a pair of neighbors, a father and his daughter. A week after the death of the girl, Susan, her family, in-laws, and niece went to the mall for a day of shopping, with Susan claiming she planned on buying Richard a birthday present. As Kate lay bleeding on the street, emergency personnel are parked behind a barricade; they were ordered to wait for the area to be cleared. Carol Atkinson. After the fifth, she calls Hotch personally and requests the BAU's assistance. Lewis gets an opportunity to visit Reid and act as his personal psychiatrist, since she has a Ph.D. Lewis gives Reid a cognitive interview; it is during that interview when Reid reveals he stabbed Nadie to death. They found out about Peter Lewis and his connection with the BAU, and decided to use his M.O. One night, Lindsey and Katie went to watch a movie at the theater. Once Reid returns to the U.S., Prentiss hires a lawyer, Fiona Duncan, for him. Taking both of the girls to an abandoned house on the outskirts of town, Ryan and his friends sadistically tortured Katie for hours, with the torture culminating in Ryan strangling her to death with a belt the next day. Because she manages to escape, apparently undetected, the police arrest Reid for drug possession after they find the stash Lindsey planted in the trunk. (", She is able to know how many football fans live in a city through Google. (", The name Melissa Gordoner could be a reference to the character, She takes a year off to be with her baby like she did when she first got Meg. She was motivated by anger and jealousy towards her sister, Katie, who she believed has ruined her life from the moment she was born and how her mother let her; which is why JJ believes that Sera chose the 1999 labeled box to put Judy's necklace and earrings because it was the year Katie was born. She also cut off Bruce's medications, allowing his sadistic alternate personality called "Johnny" to slip through. The team soon suspects that the killings are related to the witness protection program.